Trump Has China Where He Needs It
Comment of the Day

February 11 2019

Commentary by Eoin Treacy

Trump Has China Where He Needs It

This article by J. Kyle Bass and Daniel Babich may be of interest to subscribers. Here is a section:

“Water keeps the boat afloat but can also sink it” is a Chinese proverb that neatly summarizes the nation’s current economic predicament. The debt that has hydrated the Chinese financial system for the past 10 years is now drowning it.

During the darkest days of the financial crisis in 2008, China launched a 4 trillion renminbi ($593 billion in today’s dollars) infrastructure plan that was accurately described as pulling the global economy out of recession. This infrastructure stimulus plan never ceased, and by 2017 the 4 trillion of spending ballooned to 14 trillion, according to China’s National Bureau of Statistics.
At first, China benefited from the economic reforms of the 1990s, its ascension into the World Trade Organization and the resultant inflow of foreign investment by Western companies. By 2009, the previous decade of strong growth meant wages and price levels had risen such that China was no longer a low-cost manufacturer. This made it implausible that exports could drive economic growth. Therefore, China’s central bank printed money to fund a gargantuan stimulus program. 

History tells us that growth that is funded by excessively rapid credit and money creation can lead to a variety of asset bubbles and to financial, credit and currency crises. A broad measure based on data from the People’s Bank of China and other agencies that includes both bank assets and shadow banking assets such as wealth management products, trust beneficiary rights and trust loans, places China’s total credit at $48 trillion, about 3.7 times its gross domestic product. That compares with $24 trillion for the U.S. despite China having an economy that is 37 percent smaller. China’s decade of rapid credit creation and investment spending has led to soaring property values, despite high vacancy, and low wage levels. These led to tepid export growth and a stagnating economy as the export industry lost competitiveness.

Eoin Treacy's view

China has a mountain of debt that is concentrated in the regional banking sector and municipal governments. In attempting to wean the economy off of reliance on stimulus they have closed off successive avenues of credit ranging from interbank loans, P2P lending/shadow banking, US Dollar denominated debt. That withdrawal of credit has been one of the primary contributing factors in the underperformance of Chinese assets over the last 18 months.

Click HERE to subscribe to Fuller Treacy Money Back to top