The spectre of sovereign default returns to rich world
Comment of the Day

January 14 2010

Commentary by David Fuller

The spectre of sovereign default returns to rich world

My thanks to a reader for this informative and topical column by George Magnus for the Financial Times. Here is the opening
The sustainability of sovereign debt hangs heavily over bond markets, and the prospects for economic and financial stability.

Since 2007, OECD government deficits have risen by 7 per cent of GDP to just over 8 per cent, and debt, excluding contingent liabilities, has risen by about 25 per cent of GDP to just over 100 per cent.

The biggest increases have occurred in Iceland, Ireland, the US, Japan, the UK, and Spain. There is no peacetime precedent for the current speed and scale of public debt accumulation and it is difficult to assess the social tolerance for high debt levels, and for the pain of protracted fiscal restraint. In several EU member states, the threshold has already been breached. The spectre of sovereign default, therefore, has returned to the rich world.

Default does not have to mean outright debt repudiation. It can mean some type of moratorium on interest payments, and the restructuring of loan terms. Richer nations are assumed to be above such measures, but not in extreme circumstances. The US abrogated the gold clause in government and private contracts in 1934, and in 1971, it abandoned the gold standard altogether.

Default can also occur via inflation, currency debasement, the imposition of capital controls, and the imposition of special taxes that break private contracts. Seen in this light, a few countries in eastern and western Europe may already be technically at risk of default.

At the moment, higher spreads on sovereign bonds and credit default swap rates do not provide convincing evidence of an imminent default crisis, per se. Japan's public debt has already risen above 200 per cent of GDP, but the government can borrow for 10 years at 1.4 per cent, while Australia's government debt is about 25 per cent of GDP, but it pays over 5.5 per cent. Other rich countries with varying debt ratios all pay roughly 3.5-4 per cent. However, the status quo is not sustainable.

Concerted fiscal restraint could trigger another recession, but the lack of it could end up in bigger default risks. Even Japan, now into its third ageing decade, may be vulnerable, while some eurozone countries, though sheltered from currency turbulence, may yet falter in their deflation commitments and compromise the integrity of the single currency as we know it.

The UK still lacks a credible debt management strategy, and the US cannot take investor goodwill for granted. There are five reasons why public sector de-leveraging may be particularly difficult in the next few years, and why, therefore, default risks loom large.

David Fuller's view The shock of the decade and counting - so-called rich countries are becoming poorer even faster than many previously poor countries are becoming richer.

Fortunately, this does not come as a surprise to veteran subscribers of this service, although it remains shocking none the less.

We have long suggested that subscribers view markets from the perspective of judges at an international beauty contest. This may sound flippant but it is a premise that we take most seriously - when investing, back the winners in terms of relative performance.

Back to top