Rosetta Probe Has Bounced Away From Landing Site and Lost Contact, Admit Scientists
Comment of the Day

November 12 2014

Commentary by David Fuller

Rosetta Probe Has Bounced Away From Landing Site and Lost Contact, Admit Scientists

It was a day when science fiction became science fact. With minute-perfect accuracy, scientists landed a probe on a comet following a ten year journey through the solar system.

The European Space Agency predicted that the first signal would arrive back on Earth at 4.03pm confirming that the Philae lander had touched down after being detached from its mother ship Rosetta.

And at 4.03pm the instruments at control centre in Darmstadt, Germany, sparked into life as the probe made contact and furrowed brows were replaced with beaming smiles and tears.

“We are on the comet!” announced Dr Stephan Ulamec, Philae’s Lander Manager. “We are sitting on the surface and Philae is talking to us.”

However initial jubilation was followed by some anxiety after it emerged that the landing harpoons had not activated, meaning that the probe was simply sitting on the soft surface without being securely attached.

Just hours later Dr Ulamec was forced to admit that the scientists had lost contact with the probe and did not actually know where it was.

"It's complicated to land on a comet. It's also complicated to understand what has happened during the landing. What we know is that we touched down and we landed on the comet. We had a very clear signal and we also received data from the lander. That is the very good news

"The not so good news is that the anchoring harpoons did not fire. So the lander is not anchored to the surface. Did we just land in a soft-sand box and everything is fine? Or is there something else happening. We still do not fully understand what has happened.

David Fuller's view

This is an amazing achievement by the European Space Agency, at an exciting time in terms of space exploration efforts generally.  It is also encouraging news for a somewhat beleaguered continent.  Yes, it is disappointing that the lander could not be anchored on the site but the ESA should still be receiving information and photos from the orbiting Rosetta craft for approximately a year. 

Here is a PDF version of The Telegraph's article.

Back to top

You need to be logged in to comment.

New members registration