Brussels Prepares 'Grand Bargain' to Save Broken EU Project
Comment of the Day

May 23 2017

Commentary by David Fuller

Brussels Prepares 'Grand Bargain' to Save Broken EU Project

The European Commission is to unveil radical plans for a eurozone fiscal union, pushing for an embryonic treasury with powers to fight economic recessions and to cope with shocks in hard-hit regions.

The EU budget authority will be backed by a joint eurozone unemployment fund, akin to social security in the US. The proposal entails an unprecedented level of shared risk among the EU eurozone states and marks a profound shift in thinking after years of rigid austerity and lack of investment.

Valdis Dombrovskis, the EU commissioner for the euro, said there would be a 'stabilisation fund' with resources to help blighted areas escape downturns. "We will give a bigger role to the aggregate fiscal stance of the whole eurozone in setting policy," he said at the European Business Summit in Brussels.

It is a belated admission that the narrow focus on debt-reduction during the eurozone debt crisis led to a contractionary bias, drawing the whole currency bloc into a deflationary vortex that ended in a 'Lost Decade' and proved counter-productive even in its stated goal of controlling the debt trajectory.

"This is something that will set alarm bells ringing in Northern Europe," said Guntram Wolff, director of the Bruegel think-tank in Brussels.

"However you design this, it will lead to fiscal transfers. All forms of insurance lead to moral hazard and then you have to deal with it," he said.

The Commission's long-awaited 'Reflection Paper' on how to relaunch monetary union on a better footing - due in early June - will call for a “fund for the protection of public investment during recessionary phases”, according to leaked papers obtained by the Frankfurter Allgemeine.

It would come under the "democratic oversight" of the European Parliament, giving it crucial legitimacy at federal level. This would rein in the over-mighty Eurogroup that effectively runs the eurozone today and acts as a law unto itself, operating in total secrecy and answering to no elected body.

While the new fund would not exactly be an EU treasury or finance ministry, it would be a major step in that direction if ever accepted by Germany and the northern creditor powers.  

Mr Dombrovskis was careful to stress that the 'grand bargain' is not a fiscal give-away to improvident high-debt states. "Every member state is responsible for guaranteeing the stability of its public finances. Where there is risk sharing, there must also be risk reduction," he said.

Yet the plan is a major shift in policy. It is similar to proposals made by French president Emmanuel Macron during France's election campaign and suggests that the policy elites in Brussels are lining up behind him, as are the Italians and Spanish.

German Chancellor Angela Merkel must now move with care. She has refused to countenance 'eurobonds' or shared liability for legacy debt - and once said they would only happen over her dead body - but has now opened the door slightly to some sort of joint issuance for future debt. 

David Fuller's view

A visionary 39 year old President of France has shocked Angela Merkel and other senior EU politicians by attempting to open the door to fiscal union.  It is a logical step, assuming Germany actually wants the EU to become a Federal State.

Theoretically, it may have at some early stage of thinking. However, judging from Angela Merkel’s ‘over her dead body’ comment immediately above, she would sooner hold hands with Donald Trump than her European neighbours.  

Here is  a PDF  of AE-P's article.

Back to top

You need to be logged in to comment.

New members registration