Brexit May Change Europe Forever But Not In the Way Mr Gove Thinks
Comment of the Day

April 21 2016

Commentary by David Fuller

Brexit May Change Europe Forever But Not In the Way Mr Gove Thinks

William Pitt the Younger already knew the full horror of Britain's predicament in November 1805, even as he celebrated the victory of Trafalgar in his last poignant but unyielding words to the nation.

Toasted as the "Saviour of Europe" at the Lord Mayor's banquet, he gently sought to deflate the misguided mood of triumphalism . "Europe is not to be saved by any single man. England has saved herself by her exertions, and will, as I trust, save Europe by her example," he replied.

Pitt had learned of Austria's crushing defeat at Ulm three days before Admiral Nelson sank the French and Spanish fleets off Cape Trafalgar. This was soon to be followed by the allied catastrophe at Austerlitz. 

The Third Coalition collapsed. Britain was left to fight alone. It took another 10 years to defeat Napoleon, and by then our public debt had spiraled above 200pc of GDP.

Michael Gove's casual use of Pitt's words to promote the Brexit causes leaves me dissatisfied, and I have no doubt that William Hague will feel the same way after reading his superb biography.  

 Nor am I persuaded by his trust in an imminent European Spring, a "democratic liberation of a whole Continent", as repressed electorates rise up across the eurozone's Arc of Depression and sweep aside the EU nomenklatura.

This is utopian dreaming. No such democratic "contagion" is about to occur in any of the Club Med countries that he lists, though Italy is the closest, its people watching bitterly as their industry withers away and euro membership paralyzes efforts to head off a slow-motion collapse of the banking system.

I had a glimpse of this last week watching Europe's enfant terrible, Yanis Varoufakis, win rapturous applause from conservative Italian businessmen at the Ambrosetti forum on Lake Como, while German and EU leaders gritted their teeth on the panel beside him.

He told them that German wage compression - a disguised form of trade mercantilism - poses a lethal threat to Italy, made worse by the EU's contractionary fiscal doctrines.  They did not need persuading.

David Fuller's view

Here is a PDF of AE-P's column.

I prefer the newspaper edition title for Ambrose Evans-Pritchard’s excellent column, used above, rather than the online title: Brexit Means Blood, Toil, Sweat and Tears, paraphrasing Churchill’s words with which AE-P concludes his analysis.

AE-P’s column is well worth reading, for what I regard as its objectivity, and also because he deals with many of the broader consequences of Brexit, which obviously would influence the UK while also extending well beyond, not least into political developments in Eastern Europe.

If so, more EU countries are likely to blame the UK for opening the equivalent of Pandora’s Box, compounding the region’s economic problems.  EU leaders will not make it easier for the UK to trade with single-currency nations, fearing that it would encourage other countries to consider similar separations.   

Politically, I am concerned for the UK’s Conservative Party, following the aggressive stance PM David Cameron has taken.  Hoist with his own petard, he has dangerously split the governing Party and this can only cause a loss of political support. 

Back to top

You need to be logged in to comment.

New members registration