Not so fast: Innovation of computer chips faces a big hurdle
Comment of the Day

August 03 2011

Commentary by David Fuller

Not so fast: Innovation of computer chips faces a big hurdle

This is an interesting article, for which I have used the headline shown in the International Herald Tribune, by John Markoff of The New York Times. Here is the opening:
For decades, the power of computers has grown at a staggering rate as designers have managed to squeeze ever more and ever tinier transistors onto a silicon chip - doubling the number every two years, on average, and leading the way to increasingly powerful and inexpensive personal computers, laptops and smartphones.

Now, however, researchers fear that this extraordinary acceleration is about to meet its limits. The problem is not that they cannot squeeze more transistors onto the chips - they surely can - but instead, like a city that cannot provide electricity for its entire streetlight system, that all those transistors could require too much power to run economically. They could overheat, too.

The upshot could be that the gadget-crazy populace, accustomed to a retail drumbeat of breathtaking new products, may have to accept next-generation electronics that are only modestly better than their predecessors, rather than exponentially faster, cheaper and more wondrous.

Simply put, the Next Big Thing may take longer to arrive.

"It is true that simply taking old processor architectures and scaling them won't work anymore," said William J. Dally, chief scientist at Nvidia, a maker of graphics processors, and a professor of computer science at Stanford University. "Real innovation is required to make progress today."

A paper presented in June at the International Symposium on Computer Architecture summed up the problem: even today, the most advanced microprocessor chips have so many transistors that it is impractical to supply power to all of them at the same time. So some of the transistors are left unpowered - or dark, in industry parlance - while the others are working. The phenomenon is known as dark silicon.

David Fuller's view The progress in silicon chip speed may slow for a while, and then computer scientists will innovate and find a new breakthrough, in my opinion. We are a clever, albeit destructive, species.

I like the spirit of Dr Patterson, quoted in the last paragraph of the article.


Back to top